Choosing a DAW Control Surface
The biggest drawback of recording with software is the lack of tactile feedback and the limitation of interacting physically with the software through a mouse and keyboard only. Mackie’s MCU and Digidesign’s ProControl were revolutionary back in the day, significantly speeding up the mixing process and enabling more intuitive and creative workflows.
But what other options are available now that recording software has matured so significantly in the past 20 years?
Whether you’re looking at a large multi-operator Avid S6 setup for film post-production, something small and portable to work on the go, or something in the middle, let’s look at some of the various options and features available in 2025 for getting the most out of your DAW.
Protocols: HUI/MCU vs. EUCON
Mackie’s MCU was the first major system on the scene, incorporating MCU/HUI protocols that were robust for their time. To this day, almost any control surface you can buy will have a Mackie HUI compatibility mode in addition to any proprietary system the manufacturer has created. It has become a de facto standard.
The major competitor is Avid’s EUCON protocol, which is faster and more robust, but is only found on their brand of hardware controllers. EUCON is available for other manufacturers’ software through licensing. In addition to Pro Tools, Apple’s Logic and Steinberg’s Cubase and Nuendo can take advantage of EUCON.
Motorized Faders and Price
A key factor in price is whether faders are motorized. The smaller the device, the less likely it is to have motorized faders. If you’re mainly using sliders and knobs to quickly adjust parameters in a software instrument, paying extra for motorization might not be a priority.
Motorized faders matter most when you use automation. Having the faders move in real time on playback makes overdubs and corrections easy.
Visual Feedback and Channel Info
EUCON controllers inherently show more channel information and plugin parameters. That extra feedback can speed up decisions, especially in large sessions.
Ergonomics: Spacing and Feel
Physical spacing of controls isn’t always obvious when shopping. Some surfaces allow generous space between faders and knobs; others pack controls tightly. Try the unit before you buy and consider how spacing affects your workflow. Overcrowded boards can feel finicky or make it too easy to bump things you didn’t mean to touch.
Expandability
Except for some small one-off controllers, most systems can be expanded to 24 channels or more by adding multiple units or companion extenders.
Speed and Latency
EUCON is Ethernet-based and typically offers lower latency than HUI/MCU units, which often run via MIDI over USB or 5-pin DIN. For most uses, this isn’t critical, but if you do fast, repeated fader moves and need to trim or overwrite manually, every millisecond can count.
Plugin Integration
Some controllers, like those from Softube and SSL, integrate with their own console-emulation plugins, which are included. That’s a bonus if you want a cohesive “console” sound beyond what your DAW provides.
Popular Medium-Sized Motorized Options
Touchscreens
Macs don’t support touchscreens, but PCs do. A good multitouch display lets you physically “touch the mix.” You can also explore products from Steven Slate, which range in size and price and are compatible with both Mac and PC.
Some people love this approach; others don’t. Depending on the angle and mounting, comfort can be a concern, and the virtual nature may not be suitable for everyone.
Need a Hand?
Still deciding? Visit your local Long & McQuade or contact us. We’ll help you pick a solution that fits your workflow and budget. Shop DAW Control Surfaces at Long & McQuade.
